Deaf Persons not allowed to board Cebu Pacific

Cebu Pacific Logo with Discrimination of Disability
Guys, this one is really for the books. I can also categorize this situation under the “Only in the Philippines” tag and presumably a classic case of sheer ignorance.

Three days ago, after I attended the meeting at the Department of Foreign Affairs (This is another story.), a nice lady from Autism Society of the Philippines (Sorry, her name slipped my mind.) mentioned about the incident involving deaf persons and was printed in Philippine Daily Inquirer. Although I heard about it from the deaf group, I still want to know more. After a few searches, I got hold of the Opinion Article of Mr. Raul Pangalangan posted only last April 11.

He explained about Cebu Pacific Airlines refusing to board ten deaf passengers on a flight to the world renowned Boracay Island. All ten were already seated inside the plane, when the crew told them to disembark, citing their policy that blind and deaf passengers had to be properly accompanied in order to be treated as regular passengers. If unaccompanied, “he/she may be accepted for carriage provided he/she can take care of himself/herself on the ground and in-flight.

The irony was that four members of the group were visiting Americans who had flown all the way to the Philippines on their own, without a hitch, and had demonstrably met the internationally stringent standards of other airlines. They had come to attend the grand centennial of the Philippine School for the Deaf, the oldest such school in the Philippines and Asia. They hadn’t been apprised of the policy in advance. Worst of all, though they were promised a full refund, what they received was short by Php590 (USD13), the agent’s service fee apparently. (In the end, only two of the passengers were allowed to board.)

Now, where in heaven’s vast expanse did they ever thought of this ridiculous policy? Granted that a deaf person belongs to the disabled sector. However, this smacks against the very basic human rights (disabled or not) of freedom to travel which is guaranteed by our constitution.

Let me enumerate why this is an absolutely absurd policy and their situation merits exclusion.

  1. Ignorance of disability. A deaf person is not a dumb person. They do not ALWAYS need a companion to interpret for them. They can read instructions and understand stewardess’ demonstration on basic safety rules and what to do in case of emergency. In other words, THEY CAN TAKE CARE OF THEMSELVES. In the first place, why were they allowed to board a plane all the way from USA if they cannot comprehend common directions?
  2. Equal treatment is not cost-free. Additional companion entails costs. I remember Philippine Airlines give 50% discounts ONLY to caregivers of disabled passenger but not all airline companies. Republic Act 7277 otherwise known as “Magna Carta for the Disabled Persons” only accords 20% transport discount for PWD on land travels although the new Republic Act 9442 covers all means of travel. Victory Liner Bus Company never provide discounts to PWDs. Why do you hassle yourself by paying for an escort if you can survive on your own?
  3. This policy humiliates the PWD and their right for independent living. Many senior citizens travel alone. Technology made a blind person navigate through the horrible streets of Calcutta, India only with an aid of his global positioning system (GPS) device. It has been known worldwide that deaf people are well-traveled group. Why can’t they travel unconstrained?
  4. Preferential treatments at times lead to a subtle form of discrimination. Wheelchaired people are first to board the plane but are always last to disembark. If they are often seated in front and don’t impede human traffic, why are they last to get off?  How often do we see especially marked “Disabled Seats” in Light Rail Transit (LRT) occupied by other non-disabled people?
  5. Right of inclusion. We want disabled people to be productive citizens in our country. We don’t want them to depend on dole outs and welfare from anyone. Traveling is one way of showing them that they are “one of us”. I remember an insulting suggestion made by a popular Metro Manila government official saying that, “Wheelchaired people must not roam around the streets because it’s dangerous for them. They should always stay at home where they are safe.” Now this comment is way too much. They are not prisoners or are not under house-arrest. Why can’t they travel?

I have always been an admirer of Cebu Pacific because they are true to their commitment of delivering low fare rates and always on time motto. But this is one area where Persons With Disabilities can cry foul and in direct violation of their human dignity.

It’s a pity because Deaf communities especially from affluent countries travel a lot. I’ve met many of them come to the Philippines from as far as UK, the Netherlands and Switzerland. They have the resources and often travel by groups. Our country is a great destination. I have interpreted more than a handful of weddings involving a foreigner and a Filipina deaf. Our deaf people use the basic American Sign Language as a form of communication, an internationally accepted language. We might even attract prospective visitors and increase our tourism revenue if we can tap this potential.

But with this dreadful and discriminating restriction, it is almost like saying, “Hey, we don’t want people like you! You have no room in our country.

This blog post also appear in Withnews:Internet News for the Disabled and the Poor.

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to Ma.gnoliaAdd to TechnoratiAdd to FurlAdd to Newsvine


  1. Richard Roehm

    It’s the Filipino caretaking industry trying to upstage the human rights. Numerous Filipino based caretaking organizations in the United States operate numerous group homes that include the deaf people. This stigma from the caretaking industry has seemingly expanded into the airlines industry where the workers fail to see the independence of deaf people.

  2. theskygirl

    It goes with the procedures in an airline. As you can see, Cebu Pacific has only Airburs 319’s and 320’s – with three to four cabin crew. It’s with their discretion if they would want to take 10 deaf people on board, not unless they have let’s say 18 cabin crew? It goes with the ratio as what aviation people would say. One cabin equals to fifty passengers I suppose for an Airbus. And think about having emergencies on board. You cannot accommodate 10 deaf people with only 4 cabin crew.

    I’m a flight attendant from a different airline. And we have standards when it comes to passenger handling. For example you have four cabin crew on board, usually your airline (again with it’s discretion) would allow 2 deaf people on board. Again, when it comes to aviation, sometimes it would be unfair if we would react negatively. Think, safety.

  3. Mike Davies

    Astonishing, isn’t it? Some Philippines airlines should take a leaf from the QANTAS book, which has led from the front when it comes to treating people with disabilities as passengers, not as ‘safety risks’. This incident gives added impetus to a multi-sectoral movement now under way in the Philippines to make public transport, in all its forms, accessible to people with disabilities. A steep but necessary hill to climb. A fundamental principle is that schools, transport, jobs, shops and offices must adapt to suit the special needs of people with disabilities. It is not that people with disabilities have to adapt to existing services.

  4. proslaviy

    Hi, how I can send PM?

  5. Parang kulang sa publicity itong incident na ito ah. Let’s make some noise.

  6. This is clearly a form of discrimination! That’s one of the reason why Cebu Pacific has been lagging from its competitors.

  7. @Jon

    Tama ka. Patulong naman sayo on how to make some noise. 🙂

    @Kevin

    Thanks to your comment. I hope that Presidentiable Mar Roxas can help us with this. 🙂

  8. Hi there Jojo! I had already e-mail this blog post and urged Senator Mar Roxas to defend the rights of our disabled citizens. They ought some respect and consideration and I hope Senator Mar would head our call.

    I would also be blogging about this incident in my blog so that I can make a contribution in making this thing as an issue and also to inform my readers about how Cebu Pacific Airlines treat our disabled citizens.

  9. That is cruel, kinda like someone comes to you and says, “don’t ride on this plane cuz you can’t hear me”

    or even

    “don’t ride my jeepney cuz you can’t hear me”

    They already are having a difficult time without being able to hear, and now they’re giving them a difficult time flying? That’s just really sad…

  10. cwxwwwxdfvwwxwx

    well, hi admin and people nice forum indeed. how’s life? hope it’s introduce branch 😉

  11. Hi there Jojo! I have an important message to relay to you about the Cebu Pacific discrimination. Senator Mar Roxas through his Chief-of-Staff has already forwarded a letter to the Cebu Pacific Management about the issue.

    Hope you can email me at kevinraychua@gmail.com so that I can forward the message to you.

    Thanks!

  12. Hello Kevin!

    Thank you very much for helping us! Please forward to me Sen. Roxas’ letter. I would love to post it here. My email address is jojomccid@yahoo.com

    Thanks again!

  1. 1 Are deaf people considered as flight risk? « Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] Are deaf people considered as flight risk? Posted on August 24, 2008 by jojomccid I received this reponse from a flight attendant codenamed “theskygirl” about my blog entry on Deaf passengers not allowed to board Cebu Pacific Airline. […]

  2. 2 Yay! I got nominated in Philippine Blog Awards! « Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] 2008. It’s a good thing that I posted exactly five articles on the last week of April namely; Deaf Persons Not Allowed to Board Cebu Pacific (April 26), Four Days of House Visits (April 26), Deaf Laugh (April 27), Deaf Humor (April 29) and On Being […]

  3. 3 Yay! My blog is finalist in Philippine Blog Awards! « Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] 2008. It’s a good thing that I posted exactly five articles on the last week of April namely; Deaf Persons Not Allowed to Board Cebu Pacific (April 26), Four Days of House Visits (April 26), Deaf Laugh (April 27), Deaf Humor (April 29) and On Being […]

  4. 4 No Hear, No Fly? | Filipino Voices

    […] shared a story about how ten persons were not allowed to board a Cebu Pacific flight to Boracay on account of being deaf, recounting the details related to an op-ed piece on the matter by Raul Pangalangan on the […]

  5. 5 10 Deaf tourists not allowed to board an airline - AllDeaf.com

    […] as regular passengers. They were very much humiliated. Please read the complete story here: Deaf Persons not allowed to board Cebu Pacific Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person Have you heard of other similar discriminating incidents in your country? Kindly share it […]

  6. 6 Cebu Pacific discriminating deaf passengers stirs attention from Filipino bloggers « Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] But at least people from outside our community are slowly taking notice of it. After making it my first blog post in April, some notable bloggers picked it up and commented about it. I have so far collected a few and […]

  7. 7 Update on Cebu Pacific discrimination: Court case filed and policy changes « Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] Update on Cebu Pacific discrimination: Court case filed and policy changes Posted on December 17, 2008 by jojomccid Here are the updates of the recent Cebu Pacific incident of not accepting deaf passengers: […]

  8. 8 Yay! First 25,000 Visits! « Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] I started to blog actively on April 26, 2008, I was able to accumulate a total of 113 blog posts including 15 MCCID owned vlog (video logs), 16 […]

  9. 9 Cebu Pacific Update: Senator Roxas Steps In « Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] interpreter in our country and has been signing for the deaf since 1992 has blogged about this at https://deafphilippines.wordpress.com/2008/04/26/deaf-persons-not-allowed-to-board-cebu-pacific/ . He is a strong advocate of Filipino Sign Language and deaf culture. I hope you share my sentiment […]

  10. 10 Cebu Pacific responds to issues regarding deaf passengers

    […] lopsided policy regarding deaf passengers, which involves no less than two incidents, one in April in a flight to Caticlan, and another in December in a flight to Cebu, involving several deaf […]

  11. 11 More Cebu Pacific Woes « Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] ineptness, sheer ignorance and rampant violation of human rights against Persons with Disabilities here, here, here, here, here and here. But again, they committed the same mistake as if they never […]

  12. 12 Cebu Pacific Airlines, the Filipino Deaf and Me | Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] To refresh everyone’s memory, I made my first blog post about them in April of 2008 when “Cebu Pacific Airlines refused to board ten deaf passengers on a flight to the world renowned Boracay Island. All ten were already seated inside the plane, when the crew told them to disembark, citing their policy that blind and deaf passengers had to be properly accompanied in order to be treated as regular passengers. If unaccompanied, “he/she may be accepted for carriage provided he/she can take care of himself/herself on the ground and in-flight.” You may read the entire post here. […]




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s



%d bloggers like this: