Are deaf people considered as flight risk?


I received this reponse from a flight attendant codenamed “theskygirl” about my blog entry on Deaf passengers not allowed to board Cebu Pacific Airline.

theskygirl, on August 21st, 2008 at 12:56 am Said:

It goes with the procedures in an airline. As you can see, Cebu Pacific has only Airburs 319’s and 320’s – with three to four cabin crew. It’s with their discretion if they would want to take 10 deaf people on board, not unless they have let’s say 18 cabin crew? It goes with the ratio as what aviation people would say. One cabin equals to fifty passengers I suppose for an Airbus. And think about having emergencies on board. You cannot accommodate 10 deaf people with only 4 cabin crew.

I’m a flight attendant from a different airline. And we have standards when it comes to passenger handling. For example you have four cabin crew on board, usually your airline (again with it’s discretion) would allow 2 deaf people on board. Again, when it comes to aviation, sometimes it would be unfair if we would react negatively. Think, safety.

I am very elated that someone from the airline industry, a flight attendant like Ms. Skygirl would go out of her way to reply. Thank you very much for commenting. You are greatly appeciated.🙂

Now, for my reaction. I believe this merits a separate blog post and not just a comment-reply. I go back to my earlier explanation about people’s general ignorance and common misconception about deafness and Deaf people.

If airline companies have policy against boarding ten or more deaf passengers because of safety concerns, does it mean that they are considered as flight risks?

Please remember that a Deaf person only has one ability lacking, the ability to hear. He can run, jump and swim just as fast as anybody else because he has complete and functioning extremities. He doesn’t need someone to lead him just like a blind person. He doesn’t need to be pushed and carried into his wheelchair just like an invalid or orthopedically impaired person. He has a complete state of mind and can recognize his surroundings unlike a mentally challenged or autistic. He can listen to instructions with his eyes. Think of Deaf people as people who are from a different nationality and don’t understand English.

For the sake of argument, let’s just say that there is an emergency situation. The stewardess would announce that something is wrong with the airplane. People started to get panicky. Do you think a Deaf person would do his own thing and not copy what other passengers are doing? Certainly not! If the emergency oxygen mask drops from the ceiling, what would you normally do? Would the ten deaf people do it differently? Do they need individual personal instructions from the crew when the “Seatbelt On” red light is flashed on the plane’s ceiling? Remember, they are not blind.

I don’t consider harping about this incident a negative reaction. I consider it as a clear violation of the Deaf’s basic human right to travel.

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to Ma.gnoliaAdd to TechnoratiAdd to FurlAdd to Newsvine


  1. Just another opinion

    I am a trained member of the American Red Cross Disaster Assistance Team
    I am a certified member of my community’s CERT (Community Emergency Response Team)
    I am a member of the State’s Emergency Preparedness for people with disabilities Task Force
    I am a member of my county Emergency Preparedness Plan

    And I happen to be profoundly deaf

    Who would TheSkyGirl prefer on her next flight? Me, or 10 hearing people who have no clue about emergency preparedness?

    TheSkyGirl needs an attitude adjustment

  2. ::: chuckling :::

    You wrote, “He doesn’t need to be pushed and carried into his wheelchair just like an invalid or orthopedically impaired person. He has a complete state of mind and can recognize his surroundings unlike a mentally challenged or autistic. He can listen to instructions with his eyes.”

    Why don’t you wheel in an invalid or orthopedically impaired person to read this passage of yours and see what kind of reaction you will get. Why don’t you have mentally challenged or autistic people read this as interpreted by a facilitator and see their reactions. Why don’t you get blind persons to read this via text-to-speech and they’ll tell you stuff that you don’t know.

    =)

    Hope you have your padding on…

    =)

  3. Dear Sir chuckling:

    Thank you for commenting on my site. I appreciate that very much.

    However, I have no intention of maligning any person with disability when I mentioned that. I simply gave a comparison between a deaf person’s disability in contrast to people with other forms of disability. I only explained that a deaf person must not be treated the same way as with the blind or others for the reason that I stated. Being humiliated by asking the deaf passengers to get off the plane when they are already comfortably seated is too much. Airline policy managers must consider that Deaf people must be treated equally.

    I have many friends having various forms of disabilities and I am in unity with them. In fact, I head a group of Filipino web designers promoting the use of accessible websites. Although I am not disabled myself, my heart bleeds with them whenever I hear or know of discrimination issues that they confront.

  1. 1 No Hear, No Fly? | Filipino Voices

    […] August 24, 2008, the very same blog shared a reaction entitled Are deaf people considered as a flight risk?, written in response to a comment posted apparently by a flight attendant apparently not of the […]

  2. 2 Cebu Pacific Airlines, the Filipino Deaf and Me | Filipino Deaf from the Eyes of a Hearing Person

    […] Then I made a series of posts about Cebu Pacific’s blatant disrespect on the rights of those with physical impairments here, here and here. Former Senator now Secretary of Department of Interior and Local Government Mar Roxas made a letter seeking for inquiry about this matter. Other bloggers even picked up this incident by creating a stir within the community. I also made a post analysis about considering deaf people as flight risk . […]




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s



%d bloggers like this: